The tin whistle and the work of a tune

In Ireland, a six-holed whistle can be a first instrument, but its simplicity tells only part of the story. Cuts, taps and rolls give a tune its shape.

The tin whistle and the work of a tune

How can an instrument with six holes ask so much of a player? The tin whistle looks plain enough: a small arrangement of holes, usually tuned in D for Irish music. It is often the first instrument children learn in Ireland. That beginning matters. A simple instrument is easy to understand in outline, and difficult to finish. The distance between knowing what the holes are for and making a tune speak is where the whistle keeps its interest.

For a visitor, the whistle offers a way of thinking about Irish music without pretending that an instrument explains a place. It does not. Still, this small one makes a useful starting point. Its shape is direct; the music made with it is not. Players decorate tunes with cuts, taps and rolls. The words sound almost like a short set of instructions, but they name decisions made inside the tune: when to interrupt a note, where to touch it, how to turn it. The whistle may be simple. Playing it well is another matter.

A whistle can be small and still leave no easy route from the first note to a convincing tune. The holes are counted; the music cannot be counted into place so neatly. A visitor listening for the instrument’s part in a tune might notice how much can happen around a note, and how quickly a decoration can become part of the tune rather than an extra laid on top. That is a way of listening, not a rule. The whistle does not hand over its measure of a player’s skill at first glance.

Factory-made whistles became common in the nineteenth century. That fact sits neatly beside the instrument’s reputation as a first instrument: it is made in a form that can be clearly described and widely recognised. But commonness is not the same as ease. The whistle’s plain design can tempt the eye into thinking the music will be plain too. It will not. Cuts, taps and rolls are not decorations in the sense of something unnecessary added after the work is done. They are part of how players shape tunes. The small instrument has room for a great deal of choice.

Doolin belongs in this story through Micho Russell, a famous whistle player. His name gives the instrument a local point of connection, and makes the question of playing well more than an abstract one. The whistle is not only an object to describe; it is also something carried by a player’s skill. There is a temptation to make a famous player stand for a whole place. That would be too simple, and the whistle has already warned against trusting simplicity too far. Better to keep the connection precise: Micho Russell was from Doolin, and he was famous for playing the whistle.

A bus window suits this kind of thought. It leaves room for a place to pass without turning every view into a grand statement. Doolin can remain Doolin, Ireland can remain larger than a single instrument, and the whistle can remain what it is: six holes, usually in D, with more possibility than its shape suggests. The view from a window does not explain a tune either. It gives the mind time to return to one. In this case, the return is to the difference between a first instrument and a player who has found a way to make it his or her own.

Low whistles, longer and deeper, became popular from the 1970s. The change in scale is easy to picture: longer, deeper. Yet the instrument’s story is not a march from small to large, or from simple to improved. The low whistle is another form, with its own place in the family. The older-looking idea of a whistle as a first instrument and the later popularity of the low whistle can sit beside each other without cancelling out. One does not make the other obsolete. A visitor need not know the whole history to hear that the word “whistle” covers more than one shape.

That may be the useful thing to carry away from the tin whistle. Its outline is easy to remember, and the music resists being reduced to an outline. Six holes, D tuning, factory-made whistles common in the nineteenth century, low whistles popular from the 1970s: these are clear facts. The rest belongs to players, and to the work of shaping a tune with cuts, taps and rolls. In Doolin, the name Micho Russell gives that work a human connection without making it a whole explanation of the place. A first instrument, then, but no promise of a first-rate performance.

The numbers: six holes; usually tuned in D for Irish music. Six holes, and still no short cut through the tune.

See also Ennis in November: Trad music and town streets.